Webster

The Constitution was made to guard the people against the dangers of good intentions." --American Statesman Daniel Webster (1782-1852)


Saturday, May 18, 2019

U-boat 96, the inspiration for the movie "Das Boot"


I remembered watching this movie for the first time in the barracks in Germany where I was stationed.  It was 1988 and someone had gone to the Video store near Nellingen Barracks and rented this movie.   We were blown away by the portrayal of the sub.  It was totally different than the movies we had seen before.  The movies we had seen were American movies and they were based in the pacific and they were made during the war and shortly afterwards.
My Copy of the movie in DVD.
    The only movie that I like better was "The Enemy Below" but that is another story.

“We all wanted the boat to be successful and to sink as much as possible, regardless of our losses,”
The myth of U-96 lives on to this day. Only a single living witness knows the truth of what happened, such was the danger of life on a Nazi submarine during the Second World War. At 103 years old, Friedrich Grade is the last living survivor of the crew of this legendary submarine.
His experience would have been useful material for the traveling war correspondent Lothar-Günther Buchheim’s novel Das Boot that was published in 1973 and which inspired Wolfgang Petersen’s feature film bearing the same name in 1981.
Caption: Air Attacks on German U-boats, WWII. Crew of German U-boat, U-664, prepare to go over side of ship during attack by two Avenger aircraft from USS Card (CVE-11), August 9, 1943. Note, the laughing sawfish insignia on the conning tower of the 9th U-boat Flotilla. Incident #3992. Official U.S. Navy Photograph, now in the collections of the National Archives. (2015/8/18

Caption: Air Attacks on German U-boats, WWII. Crew of German U-boat, U-664, prepare to go over side of ship during attack by two Avenger aircraft from USS Card (CVE-11), August 9, 1943. Note, the laughing sawfish insignia on the conning tower of the 9th U-boat Flotilla. Incident #3992. Official U.S. Navy Photograph, now in the collections of the National Archives. (2015/8/18
 
 
Grade was offered a role in the making of the movie, but instead, he chose to stay on the sidelines. His valuable knowledge, and, more importantly, his journal, would remain a secret for many more years.
Scale model of U-96.Photo: Andrey Belenko CC BY 2.0
                                                              Scale model of U-96.


In the early years of WW2, the success of German U-boats was initially very impressive.
One example is that of U-47, under the command of Günther Prien. The sub stealthily penetrated the British naval base at Scapa Flow during the night of October 13/14, 1939. It launched a torpedo, sinking the British battleship Royal Oak, then left the port unmolested.
Kriegsmarine U-boat commander Günther Prien. Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-2006-1130-500 / Schulze, Annelise (Mauritius) / CC-BY-SA 3.0
Kriegsmarine U-boat commander Günther Prien.
HMS Royal Oak floundered, and 833 crew members perished. Prien and his crew were celebrated as heroes by Nazi propaganda.

 HMS Royal Oak
 Prien even spoke at the Berlin Sports Palace and was photographed with Adolf Hitler. Magazines printed stories with the families of the German submarine commanders.
Actually, the Kriegsmarine (German Navy) had very little to oppose the formidable Royal Navy, but their U-boats were enormously successful.
A 3 inch anti-aircraft gun in action on board the British battleship HMS Royal Oak
A 3 inch anti-aircraft gun in action on board the British battleship HMS Royal Oak
Massive submarine bunkers popped up all along the Norwegian and French coasts. In a short time, the submarine fleet had sunk Allied merchant ships amounting to 4.5 million gross registered tons. Great Britain’s supply of military equipment and raw materials was at the mercy of these Nazi Wolf Packs.
A model of German Submarine U-47 viewed from the side.Photo: Rama CC BY-SA 2.0
A model of German Submarine U-47 viewed from the side.
U-96 entered service in September 1940. In December of that same year, Friedrich Grade joined the crew as Chief Engineer. The famed U-Boat departed on 11 missions, sinking at least 28 ships and causing about 1,300 fatalities until early 1943.
“An indescribably beautiful feeling, from a distance three torpedoes = three hits,” Grade noted on April 28, 1941, in his diary.
U-96 entering St. Nazaire, crew on deck.Photo: Bundesarchiv, Bild 101II-MW-3712-04A : Schlemmer : CC-BY-SA 3.0
U-96 entering St. Nazaire, crew on deck.
If these words had been discovered, it would have been the end for Grade for breach of secrecy. However, not even Grade’s wife knew about his journal. It remained hidden in the attic for 75 years, collecting dust.
That day, U-96 sank two tankers and a steamer, causing 60 fatalities. “We all wanted the boat to be successful and to sink as much as possible, regardless of our losses,” said Grade in a TV interview. Nevertheless, he emphasized: “We were not animated by heroism or any other strange thoughts.”
Captain Heinrich Lehmann-Willenbrock, commander of U-96.Photo: Bundesarchiv, Bild 101II-MW-3483-05 / Schwich / CC-BY-SA 3.0
Captain Heinrich Lehmann-Willenbrock, commander of U-96.Photo:
Grade also explained in his journal what it was like to live on U-96 where there were 45 men crowded into confined spaces and the hygienic conditions were catastrophic. “The air stinks of diesel and is alternately hot, cold and damp. Clothes are almost always stuck to the body.”
Positiv: “St. Nazaire”, März 1942, U 96, Kptlt. Lehmann-Willenbrock. Photo: Bundesarchiv, Bild 101II-MW-3712-33A CC-BY-SA 3.0 de
Positiv: “St. Nazaire”, März 1942, U 96, Kptlt. Lehmann-Willenbrock.

 

 "Das Boot" the convoy hunt

Klaus Wennemann acts as the nameless chief engineer (“LI” for short) in Wolfgang Petersen’s movie. It was Wennemann’s breakthrough role as an actor. Grade thought that the resemblance with himself was excellent.
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios
Only the vulgar tone between the protagonists as portrayed by the author Buchheim, who passed away in 2007, bothered Grade. He never liked the man, who joined the crew of  U-96 in the autumn of 1941 to take photographs of the U-boat in action.
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo: Aconcagua CC BY-SA 3.0
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo:
The movie does an outstanding job of showing the grubbiness of the men’s attire and appearance. Seeing Jürgen Prochnow, the German actor playing the submarine commandant, with his greasy dark beard and dirty shirt is an excellent portrayal of what the crew might have looked like.
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo: Aconcagua CC BY-SA 3.0
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo:
Having said that, the film mainly focuses on scenes that involve action. Like, for example, the torpedoing of a merchant ship and the ensuing flight from the escort destroyer. It is a scene that lasts for many minutes and illustrates the sheer fright of the crew suffering under a heavy barrage of depth charges.
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo: Aconcagua CC BY-SA 3.0
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo:
The audience cannot help but empathize with the crew of U-96 when the submarine shudders at every explosion. The destroyer is relentless. It never stops its search, harassing the Germans that are the heroes of the film in this particular moment.
Then comes the silence when the explosions stop. Water is leaking from up above, the sonar pings that had harassed the submarine are no more. The men of U-96 wait and wait until they finally surface, revealing an empty sea. They have survived.
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo: Aconcagua CC BY-SA 3.0
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo:
But life on a German U-boat during the Second World War was not all about the relentless pursuit of enemy destroyers.
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo: Aconcagua CC BY-SA 3.0
Film set of Das Boot at the Bavaria Film Studios.Photo:
For the most part, the crew pursued a life of extreme monotony consisting of equipment maintenance, checking the torpedo weaponry, general upkeep activities, and other essential functions that maintained discipline and kept the men alive for as long as possible.
Bavaria Filmstadt, Munich, Bavaria, Germany.Photo: Michael Kleinhenz CC BY-SA 2.0
Bavaria Filmstadt, Munich, Bavaria, Germany.
In the end, Das Boot was nominated for six Academy Awards with the director, Wolfgang Petersen, winning the accolade as Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay. The movie was an excellent effort, to say the least.
Das Boot – submarine turret, Bavaria Filmstadt.Photo: Emmanouil Kampitakis CC BY-SA 3.0
Das Boot – submarine turret, Bavaria Filmstadt

A new German TV series produced for Sky Atlantic which is based on the book and the movie was released in November 2018.

Even though the series portrays the heroes of U-96 as more refined and cleaner, it is still an entertaining take on this famous story. Besides, it would be almost impossible to recreate Wolfgang Petersen’s unnerving and grimy ambiance.
 
 

3 comments:

  1. Come visit and I'll show you the letter I have from Reinhart Hardegen when I wrote him as part of my undergrad German language course.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Murphy;

      I am planning a trip to the big Easy probably early next year. Gotta check out the additions to the D-Day Museum :). That is really cool that you got a letter from him and I will look forward to "reading it". When it gets closer, then I will give you more details and ask you some trip related stuff.

      Delete
  2. Great movie, and very true to life!

    ReplyDelete