The Constitution was made to guard the people against the dangers of good intentions." --American Statesman Daniel Webster (1782-1852)

Friday, July 6, 2018

Unsung Hero of the Cuban Missile Crisis

I ran across this article and I thought it was fascinating background on the Cuban Missile Crisis.  There was a lot of material that I already knew about the crisis,  I had also read the book The Penkovsky Papers that talked about the missile crisis,  but I remembered something about a Soviet Submarine and an incident.  Well this article reminded me of it. 
Vasili Arkhipov was a Soviet naval officer who, upon making a split second decision, prevented the Cuban Missile Crisis from escalating into a nuclear war.
It is fitting to begin three years after Mr. Arkhipov’s death. On October 13, 2002, on the 40th anniversary of the Cuban Missile Crisis, the director of the National Security Archive Thomas Blanton remarked that “a guy called Vasili Arkhipov saved the world.”

Vasili Arkhipov. Photo: National Geographic / CC-BY-SA 4.0
Mr. Arkhipov had come a long way from the peasant family that lived near Moscow in which he had grown up. Educated in the Pacific Higher Naval School of the Soviet Union, he would serve in the closing month of World War II aboard a minesweeper during the Soviet campaign against the Empire of Japan.
After that, he spent two years in the Caspian Higher Naval School and went on to do submarine service on vessels from the Soviet Navy’s Black Sea, Baltic, and Northern Sea fleets. In 1961, he became deputy commander of the new Hotel-class missile submarine K-19.
At a time when the U.S. and the Soviets were locked in a costly arms race, the K-19 was a new vessel the Soviets hoped would provide them with the ability to launch their missiles at their Cold War rival.

One of the first images of missile bases under construction shown to President Kennedy on the morning of October 16, 1962
Commander Nikolai Shumkov commanded the K-19’s maiden voyage, and his task was to test a torpedo fitted with a nuclear warhead. The detonation of this weapon formed a huge plume of radioactive water from its detonation force of some 4.8 kilotonnes.
During exercises in the North Atlantic, the K-19 suffered a major leak in its reactor coolant system. The long-range radio had also been disabled during another incident, rendering the sub unable to contact its HQ in Moscow. This incident saw several crew members, along with Arkhipov, exposed to radiation.
Arkhipov backed Captain Nikolai Vladimirovich Zateyev, who feared that the crew would mutiny out of sheer desperation, by helping him dump most of the ship’s small arms arsenal overboard in order to avert the possibility that this potential mutiny would be an armed one.

Soviet submarine B-59, in the Caribbean near Cuba
American warships that had heard the sub’s desperate short-range distress calls came to the area and offered assistance. But Commander Zateyev refused help, fearing Soviet military secrets would be compromised.
The K-19 finally made it to another Soviet submarine and its crew was evacuated. The K-19 was then towed home. This incident, it can be safely assumed, had a profound effect on Arkhipov.
About a year later during the Cuban Missile Crisis, Arkhipov was second-in-command of the Soviet Foxtrot-class submarine B-59 which was operating near Cuba at the time. As the crisis escalated, U.S. naval vessels, clearly unaware of the fact that Soviet submarines operating in the area were carrying nuclear torpedoes, dropped depth charges on those vessels in a bid to get them to surface so that they would not break the United States naval blockade on Cuba.

Map of the western hemisphere showing the full range of the nuclear missiles under construction in Cuba, used during the secret meetings on the Cuban crisis.
When they did so on the B-59, the captain Valentin Grigorievitch Savitsky believed that war had broken out and accordingly wanted to fire a nuclear torpedo at the vessels firing them on.
The three officers who were authorized to launch this torpedo, which included Arkhipov, the captain, and the vessel’s political officer, Ivan Semonovich Maslennikov, quickly reviewed their options. The captain and the political officer were in favor of firing. Arkhipov argued against launching the torpedo stating they should await orders from Moscow.
They were forced to surface at the behest of the fleet of eleven U.S. Navy destroyers and the aircraft carrier that was engaging them. It was then they learned that no shooting war had broken out between the US and Soviet forces, but by arguing against the launching of the nuclear-tipped torpedo, Arkhipov in effect had averted the start of a nuclear war between the two superpowers.

President Kennedy meets in the Oval Office with General Curtis LeMay and the reconnaissance pilots who found the missile sites in Cuba.
In fact, Washington had issued a message stating they would be using ‘practice’ depth charges to force Soviet submarines they determined to be in breach of their blockade to surface. B-59 hadn’t received that message as they were too deep to pick up radio signals.
It is worth noting that when coming under fire Arkhipov knew he was risking two things; getting killed by simply surfacing if a shooting war was in fact underway and starting a nuclear war by returning fire in such a manner if one wasn’t underway. So his coolness in making a potentially fatal decision under such serious circumstances spoke well of him.

A US Navy P-2H Neptune of VP-18 flying over a Soviet cargo ship with crated Il-28s on deck during the Cuban Crisis.
Indeed it was retrospectively appreciated just how close nuclear war really was during that time. Robert McNamara acknowledged, after a reevaluation of the circumstances and the risks of confrontation during those fateful days that the United States and the U.S.S.R. were “closer [to nuclear war] than we knew at the time.”
As for Arkhipov, after those two dangerous episodes in the early 1960s, he continued to serve in the Soviet Navy, eventually being promoted to rear admiral and becoming head of the Kirov Naval Academy. He retired in the mid-1980s and died in 1999.
He died an unsung hero and even to this day the fateful decision he took on October 27, 1962, is relatively unacknowledged and not widely known.