The musings of a politically incorrect dinosaur from a forgotten age where civility was the rule rather than the exception.
Webster
The Constitution was made to guard the people against the dangers of good intentions." --American Statesman Daniel Webster (1782-1852)
Sunday, December 10, 2017
The story behind an iconic photo from the end of the Vietnam War.
Before I get started on the background, on a personal note, my Dad is doing better, here is a pic of him in the Hospital,
When I walked in yesterday and saw the bear, I commented "How Cute.." He shot me a bird, so I figure he is feeling better. My Dad is a Vietnam Veteran and retired from the Army as a Warrant officer with CID. He is part of the reason my brother and I also served.
Now on to my story,
I remembered when I saw this picture in my history books and I always thought well of that pic because it showed a POW returning from the hardships of the Hanoi Hilton and returning with pride to his family. Well there is a backstory to the pic I found out a day ago and finally had a bit of time to post the story. All I can say was "Damm", I felt really bad for Colonel Stirm. There are pics that are iconic for the Vietnam war and I used the following pic for an Art project in high school involving the 1960's
This pic to me represented the Vietnam war back in high school.
On March 13, 1973,
photographer Slava 'Sal' Veder captured the moment that Vietnam war
veteran and prisoner of war Lt. Col. Robert Stirm was reunited with his
family. Stirm had been imprisoned in Vietnam for nearly six years, and
this photograph came to represent not only his personal victory in
returning home, but also the path to healing
the United States needed to embark on after the Vietnam War. Yet the
real story behind this photograph, titled "Burst of Joy," is far from
the happy, joyful depiction Veder captured.
In reality, Robert
Stirm's wife had written him a letter only days before his return home,
telling him she was planning on divorcing him. For Stirm, this reunion
was bittersweet – he was reunited with his family but returning to a
wife who no longer wanted to be with him. Stirm endured all the
hardships of being a prisoner of war in Vietnam only to be greeted by a
wife who had admittedly cheated on him
during his imprisonment and written him a letter stating her intent to
divorce him – but showed up to his homecoming despite it all.
Photo: Rare Historical Photos/No restrictions"Burst
of Joy" is a poignant photograph that depicts, on the surface, the joy
of a hero’s welcome. Stirm’s back is to the camera, allowing him to
serve as the epitome
of the resilient soldier who made his way home. This particular
reunion, however, was not as joyous or welcoming as the photograph would
lead you to believe. Stirm’s wife, Loretta Stirm, is seen running
toward her husband, a big smile on her face. Yet only days before Stirm
was rescued and brought home, Loretta wrote him a letter ending their
marriage. Although the photograph may symbolize the
heartwarming concept that military families could start over and heal
after the Vietnam war, this was far from true for the Stirm family.
Photo: manhhai/flickr/CC-BY 2.0After Robert Stirm’s return, his wife of nearly 20 years managed to capitalize
on their subsequent divorce. Loretta was given custody of two of their
four children, the family home, and nearly half of Stirm’s pension. At
the time, Stirm remarked: “It’s not fair. It’s just not. I’m the one
that lives with all the aches and pains from my imprisonment, but she
continues to get paid.” That certainly makes the fact that Loretta is
there in the photograph, smiling wide at her then-husband, all the more
painful. Even his children had trouble with his return. His daughter,
Lorrie, was quoted
as saying: “So much had happened—there was so much that my dad missed
out on—and it took a while to let him back into our lives and accept his authority.
Photo: Department of Defense/National Archives Catalog/No restrictions15-year-old Lorrie Stirm, Robert and Loretta’s eldest child, hadn’t seen her father in six years
when she was captured on film running towards him with her arms flung
open, ready to embrace him. Hers is the face that can truly be described
as a burst of joy – she looks like she is literally bursting to hug her
father.
The story behind the photograph may not be a happy one, but the
photographer’s story certainly is. In 1974, Slava ‘Sal’ Veder won a Pulitzer Prize
in journalism for his photograph of the Stirm family. Veder was one of
many journalists present at Stirm’s return – Stirm was flown home with
20 other prisoners of war under what was called Operation Homecoming. Veder had to make a makeshift darkroom in
a women’s bathroom in order to send the photograph out as quickly as
possible. His quick thinking and eye for that one burst of joy won him
one of the most coveted prizes for journalism in America.
To this day, Robert Stirm doesn’t like to look at "Burst of
Joy." For him, it isn’t a joyous moment surreptitiously captured; it’s a
bitter reminder of everything he endured and everything he lost when he
came home. He refuses to
hang the photograph in his home, and when asked about it, he described
his feelings as “ambivalent.” As a prisoner of war, Stirm thought relentlessly
about coming home to his family, and it was those thoughts that kept
him alive in the face of torture. Yet his homecoming was not the happy
occasion he thought about all those years, and "Burst of Joy" is a
constant reminder of that pain.
Lt. Col. Robert Stirm was a US Air Force pilot, and he was shot down over Hanoi, Vietnam, in October of 1967. Notably, it turns out he was imprisoned only one day after Senator John McCain – both were held in the infamous Hoa Lo Prison. The
American prisoners of war sarcastically called this prison the Hanoi
Hilton. Although it is unconfirmed whether or not McCain and Stirm were
acquainted, they both endured torture at this dreaded POW camp – at one
point, Stirm was reported to have weighed only 100 pounds, and he spent
nearly an entire year in solitary confinement. Despite
his terrible experiences, Stirm continued to serve the military for
four more years after his return to the United States.
Photo: Department of Defense/Wikimedia Commons/Public DomainAll
of Stirm’s children have "Burst of Joy" framed and hanging in their
homes, although their father does not. Lorrie Stirm, the eldest Stirm
child and the girl at the center of the photograph, calls it a "very nice picture of a very happy moment."
Hey Old NFO: I am glad that he is doing better, and I knew that a lot of the POW's had this happen to them and a lot of the regular GI's. Same happened to several people in my unit when I got deployed to the Gulf for DS. It is regrettable.
Glad your dad is doing better, and Stirm wasn't the only one that happened to...
ReplyDeleteHey Old NFO:
DeleteI am glad that he is doing better, and I knew that a lot of the POW's had this happen to them and a lot of the regular GI's. Same happened to several people in my unit when I got deployed to the Gulf for DS. It is regrettable.